My MacBook Repair Nightmare with ServicePlus

I feel I wanted to share my experience with ServicePlus so others don’t end up in the same mess.

A couple of months ago, my out-of-warranty MacBook Pro started randomly shutting down. I rely on this machine for work as a software developer, so this was a major problem. Hoping for a straightforward repair, I took it to ServicePlus.

Two weeks later, they called and said the issue was the logic board. The repair would cost $649 + GST. Frustrated but desperate, I paid. I collected my MacBook, thinking the problem was solved… until an hour later, mid-meeting, it shut down again.

I brought it back immediately. They agreed to “fix it again” since I had already paid. A week later, I picked it up, and the technician said they had “touched up the logic board.”

That’s when my skepticism started. What does “touching up” a logic board even mean? Hours later, the same shutdowns began.

At this point, I was nearly a month without my regular work machine, and communication with ServicePlus felt like a guessing game. Eventually, after repeated attempts and delays, they admitted the device was non-repairable and “as good as parts.” Their final offer? Refund the $649 repair fee — and if I wanted, they’d buy my “faulty” MacBook for $200.

I felt misled. They had told me they’d diagnosed the logic board as the problem, which gave me the impression the repair would work. Turns out, it was likely just an educated guess.

After this ordeal, I started looking for a real solution for my Macbook repair on Reddit and one of the guys there recommended Advanced Computers: https://www.advancedcomputers.co.nz/mac-repair/. Here’s why I now recommend them over ServicePlus:

  • Apple-certified: Advanced Computers use genuine Apple parts and proper diagnostic tools.

  • Experience and expertise: They can realistically identify whether a MacBook issue is repairable or not, and they’ve dealt with complex logic board faults.

  • Transparency: They clearly explain what’s being done and offer a real warranty. No vague “touch-ups” or half-assed fixes.

  • Peace of mind: You actually leave with a functioning machine or a clear answer — not a month of guesswork.


Lessons Learned

  1. Apple-certified repair matters — especially for logic board or CPU/GPU issues.

  2. Vague language = red flag — phrases like “touched up the logic board” are usually a sign they don’t actually know how to fix it.

  3. Know your rights — under the Consumer Guarantees Act, if a repair isn’t done with reasonable care and skill, you’re entitled to a refund or remedy.

  4. Time is money — weeks without your main machine can cost more than a slightly pricier, certified repair.

  5. Don’t settle for guesswork — if they can’t clearly explain what’s wrong and how they’ll fix it, it’s worth walking away.

Bottom line: ServicePlus promised a fix but delivered guesswork, frustration, and wasted time. Advanced Computers? They actually know what they’re doing, use genuine parts, and provide a proper warranty. If I had gone there first, I’d have saved myself weeks of stress.